Gift exchange rules

White elephant rules, and how Yankee swap and Dirty Santa differ

Everyone brings one wrapped gift, then takes turns opening a new one or stealing one that's already open. Here are the rules in order, the three that cause arguments, and the regional versions.

By GiftCrew. Published

Before the party

Send these four things with the invitation, so nobody has to guess:

  • The price limit. $20 to $30 is the most common. Say whether it's a ceiling or a target.
  • The kind of gift. Useful, funny or regifted: one word in the invitation stops a nice blanket from sitting next to a rubber chicken.
  • One gift per person, wrapped. No name tags. Nobody should know who brought what.
  • Whether gift cards are allowed. Decide now. They're the gift people argue about most.

How to play

  1. Put all the gifts in one place where everyone can see them.
  2. Draw numbers. Write 1 to the number of players on slips of paper and let everyone draw one. That's the playing order.
  3. Player 1 picks a gift and opens it so everyone can see what it is.
  4. Each next player chooses: open a new gift, or steal any open gift that isn't locked.
  5. Anyone whose gift is stolen chooses the same way: open a new gift, or steal from someone else. They can't take back the gift they just lost.
  6. A turn ends when someone opens a new gift. Then the next number plays.
  7. The game ends when the last gift is open. Player 1 then gets one final swap.

Keep opened gifts in view for the whole game. People can only steal what they can see.

The three stealing rules to agree first

Almost every white elephant argument is about one of these. Say them out loud before player 1 starts.

When a gift is locked

The usual rule: after its third steal, a gift is locked and stays with its owner. Groups of eight or fewer often lock after two, so the game keeps moving.

No stealing straight back

When your gift is stolen, you can't take it back in the same turn. You can steal it again in a later turn, if it isn't locked.

What player 1 gets

Player 1 has nothing to steal at the start. To make up for it, they get the last move: once every gift is open, they may swap with anyone whose gift isn't locked. Without this rule, drawing number 1 is the worst luck in the game.

Yankee swap and Dirty Santa

All three are the same game. The name mostly tells you where the host grew up, and what kind of gift to expect.

White elephant

The most widely used name. A “white elephant” is something costly to keep that its owner wants rid of, so the game began with regifts and odd finds. Today most groups buy something new.

Yankee swap

The name used in New England. Gifts lean practical. In some families, players swap rather than steal: you open a gift, then may trade it for any gift already opened.

Dirty Santa

The name used across the American South. “Dirty” refers to the stealing, not the gifts: expect nice presents and no mercy.

If an invitation uses a name you don't know, ask the host two things: the price limit, and funny or useful.

How many people you need

  • Fewer than 4: too few gifts to steal. Give gifts directly, or draw names for a Secret Santa.
  • 4 to 8: works well. Lock gifts after two steals.
  • 9 to 20: the best size. Lock after three steals, and allow about half an hour for every ten players.
  • More than 20: split into two circles, or allow one steal per turn so the game ends in under an hour.

An odd number of players is fine. Everyone brings one gift and takes one home, whatever the count.

Variations worth trying

  • Unwrap at the end. Players steal wrapped gifts, judging by size and shape, and everyone unwraps together.
  • Dice. Roll on your turn: an even number opens a new gift, an odd number steals.
  • Left and right. Everyone holds a gift while someone reads a story, passing it left or right each time they hear the word. Good for children, and for groups that dislike stealing.
  • A theme. Everything for the kitchen, everything under $10, or everything in one color. A theme makes gifts easier to choose and compare.
  • On a video call. Everyone opens their own gift on camera. A steal means the two players post their gifts to each other afterwards, so keep them small.

Need a gift for it?

Bring something half the room would use. These three are safe in almost any group, and prices change, so check yours against the limit.

Links marked Amazon are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, GiftCrew earns from qualifying purchases. The price is the same for you.

For more, grouped by price limit, see white elephant gifts people actually steal.

Frequently asked questions

How many times can a gift be stolen in white elephant?

The usual rule is three: after its third steal a gift is locked and stays with its owner. Some groups lock it after two. Agree the number before the first gift is opened.

Can you steal a gift straight back?

No. If someone steals your gift, you can steal from anyone else or open a new one, but you can't take the same gift back in that turn.

What does the first player get for going first?

The first player has nothing to steal on their turn, so most groups give them the last move: when every gift is open, player one may swap with anyone whose gift isn't locked.

How many people do you need for a white elephant?

Four is the least that works, and six to twenty is ideal. With more than twenty the game runs long, so split into two circles or limit each turn to one steal.

How long does a white elephant game take?

Allow two to three minutes per player: about half an hour for ten people and an hour for twenty.

Is white elephant the same as Secret Santa?

No. In a white elephant nobody knows who gets which gift, and gifts are bought for the whole room. In a Secret Santa everyone draws one name and buys a gift for that person. See how to organize a Secret Santa.

More gift guides

Prefer gifts chosen for each person?

A Secret Santa gives everyone one name and one wishlist to shop from. GiftCrew draws the names in one tap, keeps them secret and shows each Santa their person's wishlist. Secret Santa is free.