Start with three questions
Even when you barely know the person, three questions narrow things down quickly:
- What do they use every day? A nicer version of something they already use is rarely wrong.
- What do they talk about? A hobby, a sports team, a pet or a favorite show gives you a theme.
- What wouldn't they buy for themselves? On a small budget, a little luxury beats something practical they'd pick up anyway.
The best shortcut is their wishlist. If your group draws names in GiftCrew, open your person's list after the draw. If it's empty or out of date, ask for an update: they only see that someone asked, never who. Still setting up the exchange? Start with our guide to organizing a Secret Santa.
Ideas under $15
Small budgets reward gifts that feel chosen: something to enjoy, to use up, or to keep on a desk.
Some shop links below are affiliate links: if you buy through one, GiftCrew may earn a commission. The price is the same for you.
- Fun socksAmazon (opens in a new tab)
The classic for a reason: cheap, useful and easy to match to a hobby or an inside joke. Pick a pattern for their sense of humor, not yours.
- A small-batch candleEtsy (opens in a new tab)
A handmade candle feels more thoughtful than a supermarket one at the same price. If you don't know their taste, stay with gentle scents like vanilla or cedar.
- Gourmet hot chocolateAmazon (opens in a new tab)
A treat they'll use up, which suits someone you don't know well: no clutter and no guessing about their style.
- A pocket notebookAmazon (opens in a new tab)
For the person who's always writing things down. A good paper notebook is a real step up from the free ones handed out at conferences.
- A personalized keychainEtsy (opens in a new tab)
Their initial or name makes a small gift feel made for them. Personalized items take a few days to make, so order early.
- A hand cream setAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Welcome on almost anyone's desk in winter. Choose a light or unscented one if you're unsure.
Ideas from $15 to $25
The most common office budget: enough for something useful that still feels like a treat.
Some shop links below are affiliate links: if you buy through one, GiftCrew may earn a commission. The price is the same for you.
- A coffee or tea samplerAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Several small bags let them try something new without committing to a big one. Find out first whether they're a coffee or a tea person.
- A portable chargerAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Useful for anyone who commutes or travels, and one of the few tech gifts that fits this budget well. A slim one that fits a pocket gets carried; a heavy one stays in a drawer.
- A party card gameAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Good for the friend who hosts: a gift they'll enjoy with other people, and one that comes out every holiday.
- A novel in a genre they loveAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Only if you know what they read. Add a short note on why you picked it; the note is what makes a book feel personal.
- A handmade ceramic mugEtsy (opens in a new tab)
Every desk has a mug, and a handmade one gets noticed and used every day.
- A small ceramic planterEtsy (opens in a new tab)
Add a succulent from a local shop and it brightens a desk and survives forgetful watering.
Ideas from $25 to $50
Common for exchanges among friends and family. At this level you can give something they'll use for years.
Some shop links below are affiliate links: if you buy through one, GiftCrew may earn a commission. The price is the same for you.
- Wireless earbudsAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Affordable earbuds have become good, and a reliable pair gets used every day. Choose a well-reviewed pair over an unknown brand at the same price.
- A cozy throw blanketAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Hard to get wrong in December, and it lasts for years.
- A skincare gift setAmazon (opens in a new tab)
A set from a known brand feels more generous than one full-size product. Skip strong fragrance unless you know their taste.
- A hobby starter kitAmazon (opens in a new tab)
Watercolors, embroidery, sourdough: a starter kit turns “I've always wanted to try that” into a weekend plan. Only choose one if they've mentioned the hobby.
- A custom pet portraitEtsy (opens in a new tab)
For anyone whose phone is full of their pet. Artists need time, so order at least three weeks before the exchange.
- A personalized leather card holderEtsy (opens in a new tab)
Practical and personal at once. Their initials make it theirs.
Ideas by who you drew
A coworker you barely know
Stay with things to enjoy, to use up, or to keep on a desk: hot chocolate, a sampler, a notebook, a mug. Avoid clothing sizes, perfume and anything that comments on someone's looks or habits. For more on exchanges at work, see GiftCrew for the office.
A close friend
This is where inside jokes and personalized gifts shine. Think of the thing they keep almost buying, or a gift that points back to something you did together.
Someone in your family
Lean toward things for the home or for time together over the holidays: a card game, a throw blanket for movie nights, or a photo of a shared memory in a good frame.
Someone who seems to have everything
Upgrade something they use daily, give them something to use up, or choose something made just for them. Our guide to gifts for someone who has everything has more ideas.
Get the timing right
- Order two weeks before the exchange. That leaves room for slow delivery, and for a replacement if something arrives damaged.
- Allow three weeks for anything personalized. Engraving, custom portraits and printed names are made to order.
- Ask for a gift receipt. It lets them swap a size or a duplicate without anyone feeling awkward.
- Stay within the budget. Going well over makes the gifts around yours look small. The agreed amount is a ceiling.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good Secret Santa gift for a coworker?
Something to enjoy or use up, or something for their desk: gourmet hot chocolate, a coffee or tea sampler, a good notebook or a handmade mug. Avoid clothing, perfume and joke gifts unless you know the person well.
What can I get for a $20 Secret Santa?
A coffee or tea sampler, a portable charger, a party card game, a novel in a genre they love or a handmade ceramic mug all sit around $20.
Is a gift card a good Secret Santa gift?
It's practical, but it can feel impersonal next to wrapped gifts. If you give one, make it specific to them, like a card for their favorite café, and add a handwritten note.
What if I drew someone I don't know at all?
Check their wishlist first. If they don't have one, ask a colleague or friend who knows them, or choose something most people enjoy, like a treat or a cozy blanket. In GiftCrew you can ask them to update their wishlist without revealing who asked.
Make the next draw easier
With GiftCrew, your group draws names in one tap, everyone shares a wishlist, and Santas can ask for an update without giving themselves away. Secret Santa is free.